Courtesy of Neighborhood Commission Office
Source Neighborhood Commission Office
KAIMUKI NEIGHBORHOOD
BOARD
REGULAR MEETING
MINUTES WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 16,
2009 LILI'UOKALANI ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
CAFETERIA CALL
TO ORDER: Chair Vernon Tam called the meeting to order at 7:22 p.m.
with a quorum of eight (8) members
present. Note - This 11-member Board requires
six (6) members for a quorum and to take official Board
action. MEMBERS
PRESENT: John Cater, Daniel Carvalho, Ginny Meade, Leonard Tam, Vernon Tam,
Lori Yamada, Abigail Leong and Tim
Tybuszewski. MEMBERS
ABSENT: Daniel Nahoopii and Sharon
Schneider. VACANCIES:
There is one vacancy in Subdistrict
1. GUESTS:
Lieutenant C. Tony, Sergeant M. Asato, Officer M. Mitchell (Honolulu Police
Department); Charles Djou (Councilmember); Kainoa Kaumeheiwa-Rego (Councilmember
Djou’s Office); Lorna Heller (Board of Water Supply); Barbara Marumoto
(State Representative); Candace Van Buren (Representative Nishimoto’s
Office); Les Ihara, Jr. (Senator); Ann Kobayashi (Councilmember); Jay Ishibashi
(Mayor’s Representative); Lydia Chock (Leahi); John E. Kobayashi
(KBP);Charles Fortner (Clearwire); Bob Hazzard (Diamond Head Plumbing); Tim
Robinson (Stitch This); Eugene ‘Bucky’ Yee (Elite Limo); Lori Clegg;
Sandie Chong; Gavin Sugute; Caron Wilberts; E. Fujishima; Ryan and Tysha
Konishi; Debbie Sekine; Gail and Oren Sugita; Yukie Oba; Karen Arincorayan;
Harriet Young; Richard C. Young; Martin Read; Matt Dyer; Kay Saito; Elsie
Nakamura; Ward Almeida; Albert Medeiros III; Winton Young; Bobby Spry; Patrick
McCreary; Pat Miller; Mat Buckman; Fabian Fich; Michael Elbrough; Eric Bachmann;
Jason and Marina Miller; Patrick Bustamante; Ye Nguyen; Brian Lee; Fran and Hal
Hallonquist; G. Dehart; Mike Cusanie; Kris Abe; Edward Phillips; James Phillips;
Sean Nawhall; Glenn Yamasaki; Butch Farm; Nancy Takasaki; Michael Willett;
Chelsie Takasaki; Glen Takasaki; Charlotte Loo; Norma Nakamura; Ed Hanlon; Traci
Hanlon; Jill Barry; Lynn Nakagawa; Jen Macagnone; Roy Ohye; Don Clegg; John
Enomoto; Steven Opston; S. Sonoda; Don Fujiyama; Dori Smith; Stanley Chang; Loke
Simon; Lori Lee; Gordon Ishibitan; and Theona Kapoi (Neighborhood Commission
Office
Staff). PUBLIC
SAFETY
REPORTS: Honolulu
Police Department (HPD) – Lieutenant C. Tony, Sergeant M. Asato, Officer
M. Mitchell distributed a report for the time period between August 14, 2009 and
September 14, 2009. It includes home safety tips and contact information
residents may refer
to. Honolulu
Fire Department (HFD) – No representative
present. Board
of Water Supply (BWS) – Lorna Heller
reported:
·
Main Water Break Report: None for the month of August.
·
General Water Announcements:
o Water
Emergency Preparedness: Hurricane Felicia served as an important reminder of why
we all need to be prepared. Having an emergency kit ready with at least one
gallon of water per person per day for at least five to seven days is water
emergency tip listed in the handout BWS has prepared. It is important for
everyone stay tuned to media reports as BWS will issue water information
bulletins and appropriate actions to be taken. The BWS website has more on
emergency preparedness information at
www.boardofwatersupply.com.
The pacific hurricane season continues until the end of November.
o Water
Saving Tips: 1) When mowing the lawn, leave the cuttings. The added organic
matter helps your soil retain moisture and leaves you with a reason to not rake
up after you are finished. 2) Instead of dumping leftovers from dinner into the
disposal that uses water, start a compost pile that will help soil retain
moisture and nutrients as well as help you save water and fertilizer in the
yard.
·
Follow up from August
concerns:
o Emergency
Water Amount: BSW recommends one gallon of water per person for five to seven
days because it is what is recommended by the city.
o
Contingency Plans: BWS has to review and update current hurricane emergency
plans. BWS does plan to build more reservoirs to provide water
accordingly.
o Generators
at Main and Sub Stations: Some sub stations cannot be reached in a timely manner
and generators will be provided to where it is necessary. BWS will try to get to
all stations, but it is recommended to have your own emergency
water. PUBLIC
INPUT AND
CONCERNS: Announcement
– Waialae Avenue will be closed to traffic and parking in both directions
beginning at 6:00 a.m. on November 7th between 11th Avenue
and Koko Head
Avenue. NEW
BUSINESS: Bill
52-2009 Application to re-zone property at 1049 12th Avenue
– Discussion
in favor of Bill 52-2009 application to re-zone property at 1049 12th
Avenue –
- • ‘Stitch This’ is not the cause of
traffic problems. The owner goes off site to various customer locations and
brings the items back to the shop for necessary repairs. There are very few
customers that drop off and pick up items.
- • An independent professional traffic survey
has been submitted with the zoning application and has determined that even if
the property owner were to rebuild (currently there are no intentions to do so)
no mitigation changes would be required. A set number of parking stalls is
required by the building department depending on what it is the property owner
plans to do on the property. Illegal street parking is not the caused by the
property owners business. Residents on the street and other business owners are
all guilty of parking in the “No Parking” zones. Property owner
suggests removing all street parking, or working a ‘Resident Parking
Only’ permit system; which will allow only residents on that street to
park. The map of the area is mainly zoned as B-2. There are only 2 remaining R5
lots on the property owners block.
- • Facts have been presented in support of
‘Stitch This’ and the property owner and would like the board to
consider rezoning the property. Pictures the property owner presented show that
he was not the one who turned Kaimuki into a business district, it was already
there.
Discussion
in opposition of Bill 52-2009 application to re-zone property at 1049
12th Avenue
–
- • Resident request the denial of rezoning the
property from Residential zoning 5 to Business zoning 2 because once that is
done, there is no turning back. There already are current empty business spaces
that may be filled instead of rezoning what is left of the R5 areas in the
Kaimuki area. Residents would like to preserve what is left of the residential
area. They are not against the property owner; they wish him well in his
business. Residents are against rezoning the area because it is on a smaller
dead end street.
- • Resident grew up in the 12th
Avenue area. The planners and developers do not live in the area they want to
change and do not understand what’s going to happen. Not rezoning the area
will protect long time residents that have resided in the area. Although DPP
currently agrees with rezoning the area, to do so is a legislative action and
the will of the people play an important
role.
Neutral
Testimony to Bill 52-2009 application to re-zone property at 1049
12th Avenue
–
- • The current Kaimuki area took 17 years before
the new design of the town came to what it is. There needs to be proper
planning, organization and something agreeable to all
parties.
Testimony
in favor of Bill 52-2009 application to re-zone property at 1049 12th
Avenue –
- • ‘Stitch This’ has always done
well for an individual boating business. If there were a need to go to
12th Avenue, parking would be provided in the drive way and there
wasn’t an issue with having constant traffic. ‘Stitch This’
owner would go out to do a job. Business owner doesn’t understand why
‘Stitch This’ is being discriminated against.
- • ‘Stitch This’ has been a huge
help with innovation for the sport of canoe paddling. The prices the company has
given has been helpful for getting what the paddling team needs. Most of the
work he has done for the paddlers have been out at beach sites. ‘Stitch
This’ is already located in a business district and change should be
permitted. If there are times for a need to go to the 12th Avenue
address, there would always be room in the drive way to park.
- • A current resident and former employee living
at the ‘Stitch This’ address stated the business is not the cause of
traffic in the area. Currently limousines are parked on the street in front of
the houses. More respect has to be given to the residents in the area.
‘Stitch This’ does not take any street parking. There have been many
changes in the community and the owner of ‘Stitch This’ is a large
asset to the community. It has been suggested to look at all the facts and give
this business owner a fair
chance.
Testimony
in opposition of Bill 52-2009 application to re-zone property at 1049
12th Avenue
–
- • The owner of the parking lot behind the
property in question is zoned as R5 with a conditional use permit for the
parking. He bought the empty lot to provide parking for the building. The City
wanted him to rezone his property to a B2 but the value would go up to $35,000 a
month across parking stalls and I told them I didn’t want to rezone the
property. Suggested ‘Stitch This’ owner get a conditional use permit
so there is no need to rezone. There are a lot of empty business places
‘Stitch This’ can move into. As residents of the area, we need to
preserve all that we can for the neighborhood.
- • The owner of Elite Limos does have limos
parked on the street, but it is not illegal because it is made for parking.
Elite Limo owner stated ‘Stitch This’ owner would use the parking
space for cutting materials outside of his property. The area would be more
congested if a new business were to be built in an already congested
area.
- • Resident is interested in the parking for the
area should rezoning happen. Resident spoke with a law enforcement officer who
reviewed all the letters and concluded that the business is more than just a
home occupation business. The officer also commented that the area is not
suitable for rezoning and should be kept the way it is.
- • The younger generation will not get to
experience what Kaimuki once was. Rezoning the area would have a negative impact
and would make it difficult for street access. It is an old residential area and
should remain that way. It should be considered to work out of empty zoned
business spaces. Over 200 residents in the neighborhood signed a petition in
opposition to the
rezoning.
Yamada
moved, Cater seconded the Kaimuki Neighborhood Board No. 4 support the
resolution opposing the rezoning of 1049 12th Avenue Parcel from R-5
to B-2. Discussion
followed:
- • Meade questioned the audience members who
were the longest living residents that live on 12th Avenue. The
longest by far has been living there pre 1927, then 1993 followed by a resident
living on the street since 2000.
- • Meade also questioned the resident who owns
the parking lot next to the 1049 12th Avenue address and if his
‘conditional use’ permit was brought before the board? His response
was
no.
The
motion to support the resolution opposing the rezoning of 1049 12th
Avenue Parcel from R-5 to B-2 FAILED TO BE ADOPTED,
4-3-1 (AYE: Cater, L. Tam, Yamada, Carvalho; NO:
Leong, Meade, Tybuszewski; ABS: V. Tam). (Attachment 1 – 1049
12th Avenue
Resolution). Clearwire
Wireless at Kaimuki Middle School – Charles Fortner, Clearwire
representative reported the
following:
- • Due to the growing demand for wireless
internet service in the Kaimuki area, Clearwire would like to submit an
application for a Conditional Use Permit to build a small wireless facility on
the rooftop of the Kaimuki Middle School. The proposed installation includes
extending an existing elevator penthouse with 6 ft panels matching the existing
building that would hide the equipment. Clearwire’s equipment would not be
seen.
Questions,
comments and concerns:
- • There are no safety issues concerning this
wireless facility. There is a six foot safety distance and the towers being
built are lower than the average towers normally used for wireless internet
service. Again, to minimize visual impact, the new panels will match the
existing building to hide any necessary equipment.
- • There is a program that will have Clearwire
technicians regularly check on the equipment. The system does not use much
voltage – between four and eight amps, equivalent to an air conditioner
unit.
Human Trafficking Bill – Kathryn Xian,
from Pacific Alliance to Stop Slavery (PASS) reported the
following:
- • Hawaii is one of eight states in America that
has not passed a Human Trafficking State Law. The growing number of trafficking
activity worldwide is making it difficult for the federal government to regulate
all 50 states. In Hawaii, if ‘pimps’ are caught they usually are
prosecuted for promoting prostitution; which has a maximum of 10 years in prison
and $25,000 fine and a minimum one year in prison and $2,000 fine. PASS’s
goal is to end trafficking in Hawaii through education, advocacy, outreach,
intervention and prevention. PASS requests the support for Anti-Human
Trafficking legislation. Currently, PASS has outreach programs in Waikiki, local
schools and is looking to gain support from Neighborhood Boards on Oahu as well
as the Senate and House of Representatives.
- • Formed in 2009, PASS is a coalition of both
secular and faith-based groups located in Hawaii who share a common mission to
educate the public about the growing problem of human trafficking, advocate for
the passage of local state legislation, and to ensure the enforcement of such
legislation to especially focus on prosecuting ‘pimps’ and
patrons.
- • The demand for children is on the rise as the
pornography business grows. The youngest child reported to have contracted aids
was nine months old. Children are kidnapped, sold, forced, or born in brothels
and become victims. Over 17,500 children and women are annually trafficked into
the United States for sexual services and the trend is accelerating.
- • This upcoming legislative term is the third
year it will be presented to the State
Legislature.
Meade
moved, Tybuszewski seconded to support the resolution for Human Trafficking. The
motion was ADOPTED UNANIMOUSLY, 8-0-0 (AYE: Cater, Leong, Meade, L. Tam, Yamada,
Carvalho, V. Tam, Tybuszewski). (Attachment 2
– Human Trafficking Resolution).
1039
11th Avenue Application to Re-zone Update – Lori Clegg
reported:
- • November 2008 was the original presentation
for this zone change. The application was turned in to the Department of
Planning and Permitting (DPP) and the recommendation for the zone change has
been accepted. It is a 4,000 square foot property that was set aside by the
Department of Transportation (DTS) when the freeway was built and later
purchased by a private owner.
- • On September 9, 2009, DPP presented
information to the planning committees who okayed the project. There are no
current plans to redevelop the property as it is too small. However, it may
provide an entry way to buildings and more
parking.
ELECTED
OFFICIALS OR THEIR
REPRESENTATIVES: Mayor
Mufi Hannemann’s Representative – Jay Ishibashi
reported:
- • Mayor Hannemann continues to work on the
collective bargaining negotiations.
- • In early September, Mayor Hannemann and
fellow mayors, went to Los Angeles to promote Hawaii as a visitor destination.
Organized by the Hawaii Visitors and Convention Bureau, the mayors participated
to demonstrate how important the industry is to the economy and
workforce.
- • At the last meeting, the Board received a
copy of all the coring sites in the Kaimuki Neighborhood Board area. However, no
map has been provided.
- • Ishibashi will get back to the board
regarding the request to have the City and County of Honolulu help with the
erection of the Kaimuki Christmas tree. Budgetary concerns and cuts may limit
the county’s involvement this year.
- • The mahogany tree leaves on 10th
Avenue and Kaimuki Avenue were swept on September 15,
2009.
Questions,
comments, and concerns:
- • The Kaimuki Christmas tree is a public and
private partnership. KPPA and GECA have spent $3,500 last year to replace or get
new lights for the tree. The least the Department of Facility Maintence (DFM) or
the Department of Parks and Recreation (DPR) could do is put up a tree before
the end of October
2009.
City
Councilmember Ann Kobayashi – Councilmember Kobayashi circulated a
newsletter and reported the
following:
- • Bulky items are becoming a problem that she
is trying to resolve. If residents have bulky items to pick up, call the office
and they will try to assist with notifying when the bulk item pick up days are
scheduled.
- • There has been a resolution drafted to know
how the rail transit money is being spent. It has been questioned about the way
the money being spent not public
knowledge.
Questions,
comments and concerns:
- • A question regarded how a $1 billion bond
will effect residents. The pay back on borrowing such a large amount of money
will amount to about $4 billion dollars.
- • A comment noted if property taxes could be
lowered.
- • A concern regarded when old neighbors move
out a mess is left along the road side creating a problem for the new residents
moving in.
- • Kaimuki High School will host the
6th Annual Aloha Aina Earth Day on Saturday, October 17,
2009.
City
Councilmember Charles Djou – Councilmember Djou circulated a newsletter
and reported the following:
- • Welcome back to Councilmember Ann
Kobayashi.
- • Sidewalk sleeping ban is not appropriate and
doing nothing is not acceptable.
- • Shark tours are already illegal in the state
and the Council is trying to ban commercials and marketing for these tours. The
difficulty is the enforcement on the water.
- • Real Property Tax Exemption: For anything
that allows for renewable energy.
- • Increase of Home Owners Tax Credit: The
current $80,000 has been introduced to be increased to $100,000; this has not
yet passed.
- • Councilmember Djou is in support of Pacific
Allienance to Stop Slavery proposal.
- • The plastic bag ban has been deemed stuck in
committee.
Governor
Linda Lingle’s Representative – reported the
following:
- • Currently our economy is down $3 billion. The
state is trying to find ways to close the deficit. Some ways this has been
happening is by putting a freeze on hiring, travel and new equipment. The state
is trying to use federal stimulus monies and finding ways to get
more.
- • Current union negotiations have not come to
an agreement. If no agreement has been made, there will be layoffs. Teachers
have made an
agreement.
Questions,
comments and concerns:
- • Governor’s Representative will have to
report back on the mental health administration
situation.
State
Senator Les Ihara – reported the
following:
- • The Senate went into special session and
voted to confirm Craig Nakamura as chief judge of the Intermediate Court of
Appeals
- • Senator Ihara is working with two community
members regarding care home issues. They met with DPP and major branch chiefs
are working on how to regulate care home work with care home associates. They
would like to see community support for regulated care homes.
- • Senator Ihara may be contacted at
808-586-6250.
State
Representative (House Speaker) Calvin K.Y. Say – A newsletter was
circulated. State
Representative Barbara Marumoto – A newsletter was circulated and
Representative Marumoto may be contacted at
anytime. Questions,
comments and concerns:
- • Resident is concerned with neighbors from
Vietnam. She is not able to indicate their ethnicity on the complaint form.
Resident was informed that the ethnicities on the forms are done by reaching a
certain criteria. The number of Vietnamese people needs to reach a critical mass
to be specifically identified. The State Department of Labor may be able to
assist with the matter and have the Office of Languages help with language
barriers.
State
Representative Scott Nishimoto – A newsletter was
circulated. State
Representative Lyla Berg – A newsletter was
circulated. APPROVAL
OF MINUTES FOR MAY 20, 2009 AND AUGUST 19, 2009 MEETING:
The meeting minutes of May 20, 2009 and
August 19, 2009 were APPROVED AS CORRECTED by UNANIMOUS CONSENT (10-0-0)
(AYE: Cater, Leong, Meade, L. Tam, Yamada,
Carvalho, V. Tam, Tybuszewski), with the
following corrections to the August 19, 2009 minutes
–
- • Page 1, Guest name Debbie Sekire should read
Debbie Sekirne.
- • Page 1, Guest name Lydice Chock should read
Lydia Chock.
- • Page 3, Both motions board member Carter
should read Cater.
- • Page 5, Approval of Minutes, board member
Carter should read
Cater.
TREASURER’S
REPORT: Treasurer Yamada reported: The previous balance was $2,964.83.
Current expenses totaling $50.54 for printing and postage of the agenda and
minutes leaving a balance of $2,914.29. Printing the agenda and minutes cost
$10.06 and the postage to mail the agenda and minutes cost $40.48. The
Treasurer's Report was
filed. ANNOUNCEMENTS:
- • The next meeting of the Kaimuki Neighborhood
Board will be Wednesday, October 21, 2009, 7:15 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. at
Liliuokalani Elementary School.
- • There will no longer be reimbursements for
refreshments as of September 2,
2009.
ADJOURNMENT:
The meeting adjourned at 9:15
p.m. Submitted
by: Theona Kapoi, Neighborhood
Assistant Reviewed
by: Vernon Tam,
Chair *Attachment
1 – 1049 12th Avenue
Resolution *Attachment 2 – Human
Trafficking Resolution |
|